Primary Landing Page

Aims

Focusing on governance issues related to three major and interconnected challenges– a rising public health burden, social inequality and climate change - the Hothouse will provide a roadmap towards planetary health equity.

Our work seeks to answer the question: What are the conditions that enable the transformation of the consumptogenic system and ensure the development of intersectoral public policy and commercial activities that advance planetary health equity goals?

The goal of the Laureate is to generate new knowledge about ways to improve the common drivers of climate change and global health inequities and identify how the consumptogenic system can be transformed towards planetary health equity goals. The aim is to drive positive change through idea generation and informed action in policy and business.

We will do this through a governance-focused study of the consumptogenic system, revealing how powerful interests, ideas and institutions enable or hinder the development of intersectoral policy and commercial activities that advance planetary health equity. Based in systems thinking, the research brings together planetary, social and commercial determinants of health inequities.

HH The Problem

Research Program

The Laureate research program has the following five objectives, addressed through three work packages with two interrelated streams. Initial case studies will focus on food, energy, and infrastructure/housing.

1. Conduct a political economy analysis of the consumptogenic system driving planetary health inequity.

2. Identify inter-sectoral policies and commercial activities to improve planetary health equity, across key sectors.

3. Understand how state, market and civil actors advance their interests and influence policy and business processes relevant to planetary health equity.

4. Provide the theoretical and analytical advancements to develop a governance framework that advances planetary health equity coherent policies and business practices.

5. Identify strategies that socially-oriented actors in government, international organisations, non-government organisations, and business can use to transform the system to advance planetary health equity goals.

HH Research Design

Work Package 1: Exposing the consumptogenic system

We will systematically expose the key macro-economic, political and social drivers of the consumptogenic system in Australia and globally, thus identifying where action needs to focus. We will map the state, market and civil society actors in these systems, producing network maps showing the different types of actors involved in the general and sector-specific planetary health inequity systems, how they are linked and who holds the key levers for change.

Work Package 2: Planetary health equity impact assessment

We will qualitatively assess the impact of current intersectoral policy and commercial activities on planetary health equity and make recommendations for changes to enable coherent policies and business practices that could recalibrate the consumptogenic system towards planetary health equity. A planetary health equity impact assessment tool will be developed.

Work Package 3: Governance to advance planetary health equity policy and business practices

Fundamental to effecting positive change in the consumptogenic system is an understanding of key decision-making processes. We will examine the challenges and opportunities for creating the coherent policy and business practices identified in Work Package Two. This requires understanding the processes of policy-making, the structures in which business decisions are made, the power dynamics between public/private, state/non-state, health/other interests, and the strategies and tactics used by the different actors to advance their interests.

Concepts

Consumptogenic system: This global system is characterised by institutions, policies, commercial activities, norms and behaviours that encourage and reward excessive production and consumption of fossil fuel-reliant goods and services that are unhealthy and inequitably valued and distributed. The consumptogenic system is a root cause of health inequities and climate change.

Planetary Health Equity: The equitable enjoyment of good health in a stable Earth system.

Silver bullet
Scanrail on Adobe Stock

No silver bullets, no shortcuts: confronting the commercial determinants of the climate crisis

Benjamin Wood, Penelope Milsom, Sharon Friel. 7 November 2024. The Lancet Planetary Health.

A commercial determinants of health lens—highlighting the practices of commercial entities and the wider system which both enables and constrains them—can provide important insights regarding the power of the fossil fuel industry and transforming the dominant political–economic system within which it is embedded.

Read more

In this commentary, we give examples of some of the avenues by which this transformation could occur, including those that draw on financial and governance mechanisms.

https://doi.org/10.1016/S2542-5196(24)00278-X

Hothouse working paper

Working Paper 2

Explaining variation in export credit energy lending: implications for planetary health equity

Nick Frank, Maxfield Peterson, Sharon Friel.

Reading the working paper here

Hothouse working paper

Working Paper 1

Export-credit agencies: problems or solutions for planetary health equity?

Nick Frank, Christian Downie, Sharon Friel, Maxfield Peterson.

Read the working paper here.

Hothouse NCD reports paper

Climate change mitigation policy for planetary health equity? An automated content analysis of countries' nationally determined contribution reports

Megan Arthur, Nicholas Frank, Anurug Chakma, Sharon Friel. October 2024, Environmental Research Letters.

National governments’ reports to the UNFCCC under the Paris Agreement – Nationally Determined Contribution reports – are important policy documents outlining commitments to climate action. Given the significant and inequitable health impacts of climate change, the extent to which these documents discuss impacts for the social determinants of planetary health equity is therefore important.

Read more

Our analysis indicates much greater attention to economic issues than to social determinants in countries’ NDCs, particularly in high-income, high-emitting and carbon intensive economies. It seems there is a clear need to reorient policymaking toward health equity and social determinants within these critical climate change policy documents.

https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ad7edf

Financialisation and health equity

Financialisation: a 21st century commercial determinant of health equity

Sharon Friel, Ashley Schram, Nicholas Frank, Megan Arthur, Belinda Townsend, Hridesh Gajurel. September 2024, The Lancet Public Health.

As a global public health community, we must pay close attention to these commercial determinants of health. Meaningful action must be taken to ensure financial systems function in ways that promote, or at least do not undermine, health, social equity and the environment.

Read more

Transparent checks and balances must be built into these systems, with state actors using their regulatory power to guide financial practices in ways that are good for planetary health equity and hold financial actors accountable. Civil society groups can shine a light on these practices, articulate alternative visions and hold financial actors, and governments, to account. Ultimately, financial and commercial worlds must return to stakeholder primacy rather than that of the shareholder.

https://doi.org/10.1016/S2468-2667(24)00187-7

Export credit agencies and planetary health equity

Mapping networks of export credit for fossil and clean energy infrastructure: trends, persistencies, and policy options

Nick Frank and Maxfield Peterson

Official Export Credit Agencies (ECAs) have the potential to accelerate the global energy transition by de-risking energy investments and supporting climate financing objectives.

Read more

To achieve this potential, this working paper recommends: ending fossil fuel-related financing, reducing domestic content requirements for clean energy projects, expanding domestic lending and equity financing for renewable energy, and enhancing ECAs' roles through blended finance frameworks.

https://iit.adelaide.edu.au/news/list/2024/08/21/mapping-networks-of-export-credit-for-fossil-and-clean-energy-infrastructure

MJA July 2024 Hothouse perspective

Priorities for planetary health equity in Australia.

Sharon Friel, Katherine Trebeck, Nicholas Frank, Sandro Demaio, Megan Arthur, Chelsea Hunnisett, Francis Nona. July 24, 2024, Medical Journal of Australia.

Preventive action is needed to address the common underlying drivers that are jeopardising planetary health equity and to ensure the equitable enjoyment of good health in a stable Earth system.

Read more

In discussing these preventive actions, this article emphasises the urgent need to transform the consumptogenic system, with a focus on economic models, policy coherence, advocacy, and health sector leadership. 

https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52397

First page of journal article

Exploring the planetary health equity governance supercluster complex.

Nicholas Frank, Sharon Friel, Megan Arthur. April 23, 2024, Earth System Governance.

Given the inability of a single government to manage the collective challenges facing humanity, there is a pressing need to understand the governance structures required for planetary health equity (equitable enjoyment of wellbeing in a stable earth system).

Read more

This exploratory analysis indicates that structural power within the supercluster complex for planetary health equity is not evenly distributed, is highly centralised and dominated by economic governance organisations.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.esg.2024.100207

COP28 Lancet commentary

Making COP28 rhetoric a reality

Giorgia Dalla Libera Marchiori, Sharon Friel. February 14, 2024, The Lancet.

2024 must be the year of bold and inspiring nation leaders, ministers, and policy makers developing policies and establishing international treaties that prioritise health, equity, and the planet, while working to create the conditions for an economic system that supports their implementation...

Read more

This commentary reflects on what should follow COP28's successes and failures. It highlights the need to focus on mitigation policies both at national and international levels to avoid the further exacerbation of the climate-health-equity crisis. It calls on governments, especially in high-income countries, to shift towards an economic system centre on wellbeing rather than GDP to create the environment for those mitigation policies to flourish and deliver positive outcomes for people and planet, as well as reshaping COP governance to rebalance power dynamics in the decision-making process.

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(24)00199-5

Climate change mitigation. Tackling the commercial determinants of planetary health equity

Climate change mitigation: tackling the commercial determinants of planetary health inequity

Sharon Friel. November 14, 2023, The Lancet.

The findings of the 2023 report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change are not surprising, but are incredibly worrying for the survival of humanity...

Read more

Taking the necessary bold mitigation action requires disrupting the consumptogenic system, and the entrenched power inequities that exist at the core of this system. Governments, especially in high-income countries, must use their regulatory power to curb excess commercial activities and stop further coal, oil, and gas projects.

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)02512-6

New Political Economy article

Shaping planetary health inequities: the political economy of the Australian growth model

Nicholas Frank, Megan Arthur, Sharon Friel. August 8, 2023, New Political Economy.

The global consumptogenic system encourages excessive production and consumption of goods and services that are harming human and planetary health. Growth models lie at the core of the consumptogenic system...

Read more

We analysed the Australian growth model, the politics that sustain this model, and the impacts of the model on people and the planet. We show that the Australian growth model has become more reliant on domestic consumption fuelled by rising house prices and a permissive credit environment to drive economic growth. The key drivers of the Australian growth model have created conditions that undermine economic equality, drive health inequities, and create excessive greenhouse gas emissions that contribute to climate change.

https://doi.org/10.1080/13563467.2023.2242796

Thumbnail of the academic paper in the Medical Journal of Australia and The Lancet Countdown Report 2022

The 2022 report of the MJALancet Countdown on health and climate change: Australia unprepared and paying the price

Paul J Beggs, Ying Zhang, Alice McGushin, Stefan Trueck, Martina K Linnenluecke, Hilary Bambrick, Anthony G Capon, Sotiris Vardoulakis, Donna Green, Arunima Malik, Ollie Jay, Maddie Heenan, Ivan C Hanigan, Sharon Friel, ...

 

Read more

...Mark Stevenson, Fay H Johnston, Celia McMichael, Fiona Charlson, Alistair J Woodward and Marina B Romanello

November 7, 2022 

The MJA–Lancet Countdown on health and climate change in Australia was established in 2017 and produced its first national assessment in 2018 and annual updates in 2019, 2020 and 2021. It examines five broad domains: climate change impacts, exposures and vulnerability; adaptation, planning and resilience for health; mitigation actions and health co-benefits; economics and finance; and public and political engagement. In this, the fifth year of the MJA–Lancet Countdown, we track progress on an extensive suite of indicators across these five domains, accessing and presenting the latest data and further refining and developing our analyses.

https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.51742

thumbnail image of academic paper in the Medical Journal of Australia

Climate Change, society, and health inequities

Sharon Friel. November 7 2022, Medical Journal of Australia.

Climate change will widen health inequities; action on the social determinants of health is essential...

Read more

This article lays out ways of advancing planetary health equity goals. To help achieve these, the health community must advocate for and engage in intersectoral policy discussions relating to the social determinants and the structural consumptogenic system. Acting immediately on these issues is critically important if we are to avert a planetary health inequity crisis.

https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.51731

Lancet article thumbnail

Power and the planetary health equity crisis

Sharon Friel, Megan Arthur, Nicholas Frank. October 1, 2022, Invited Comment in The Lancet.

"Societies are at a pivotal juncture in addressing the impacts of the climate crisis and the consumptogenic system...

Read more

Recalibrating power inequities might be possible by compelling narration of ideas that advance equity and sustainability, strategic use of institutional processes, and social mobilisation among like-minded and unusual bedfellows."

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(22)01544-6

Enquiries

Please direct general enquiries to: hothouse@anu.edu.au 

LinkedIn: @planetary-health-equity-hothouse

Twitter: @PHEhothouse

Subscribe

* indicates required

Postal Address

The Planetary Health Equity Hothouse

School of Regulation and Global Governance (RegNet)
HC Coombs Extension Building #8
8 Fellows Road
The Australian National University
Canberra ACT 2600

CRICOS Provider: 00120C | ABN: 52 234 063 906

Please visit Transport & Parking for more information on how to find us.